Weekly
Intelligence Notes #24-01
18 June 2001
|
WEEKLY INTELLIGENCE NOTES (WIN)
#24-01, dtd 18 June 2001
WINs are produced by Roy Jonkers for AFIO members and
for WIN subscribers, for non-profit educational
purposes. Associate editors Don Harvey and John
Macartney also contribute articles.
AFIO Members -- Sponsor a New Member Today!
And If You Can -- Sponsor a Corporate Partner!
Check our Website < www.afio.com>
for details -- updated daily!
AFIO INTELLIGENCE SYMPOSIUM: Statecraft,
Tradecraft and Hi-Tech - 2001 and Beyond at CIA 2/3
November 2001 - Watch for further details on our Website
www.afio.com
and Mark your calendars
SECTION I --
CURRENT INTELLIGENCE
MIDEAST SITREP -- CIA
Director George Tenet received favorable media reporting
on his significant and unusually overt personal
diplomatic success in getting Israeli and Palestinian
security officials to agree on a scheme for ending the
reciprocal violence. With US and international moral and
diplomatic pressure applied to both sides, Arafat's
organization has won a stay of execution and can hang on
a while longer by arresting its own activists. In return
for their existence as an organization, they will get
conversations/talks/words with a reluctant Israeli
government - no concessions expected. Things appear to
have quieted down some more killings of Palestinians
(three women and a boy) and two Israeli settlers
(Premier Sharon holding his fire), but a semblance of
stability has been restored - a US objective.. The
diplomatic mission of the DCI has won significant public
media goodwill and recognition for himself and
CIA. US intelligence will remain involved on a priority
basis. (Jonkers) (miscellaneous US and world press)
SPY TRIALS 2001 SUMMARY
-- A summary of recent and current spy cases follows:
(1) FBI/HANSSEN -- The accused FBI
traitor Hanssen was arraigned on 16 May 2001 on 21
counts of espionage charged with conspiracy to commit
espionage, attempted espionage, and nineteen specific
acts of spying, fourteen of which are punishable by
death. Ten of these fourteen counts deal entirely with
communications intelligence issues. They include
betrayal of satellite interceptions and nuclear war
preparations. The grand jury cited eight examples of
compromised "communications intelligence"
instances. The specifications of interest to members
formerly involved in these matters include:
* In 1986 Hanssen told Moscow that the
United States was "exploiting" a technical
weakness in Soviet satellites to intercept
transmissions.
* In 1988 he helped the Soviets protect their
communications by disclosing a limitation on what the
National Security Agency could read.
* In 1989, he turned over a top-secret analysis of
U.S. plans to "ensure the continuity of
government in the event of a Soviet military
attack." It is speculated that might have
provided the Soviets with highly secret 'Continuity of
Government' program documents relating to secret
government relocation sites, evacuation plans,
emergency communications systems, etc. Such
information would have been of considerable interest
to the targeteers in the USSR's Strategic Rocket
Forces.
* He betrayed six Soviet citizens and agents who were
secretly working for the United States, in addition to
three KGB double agents mentioned in earlier filings.
(NOTE: Two of the US Soviet agents who were executed
were also betrayed by Ames). Intelligence interest in
this case is now focused on damage assessment. A deal
with the Justice Department to get Hanssen to
collaborate on the damage assessment in return for
ruling out the death penalty is said to be at hand. As
to Hanssen himself, his psychiatrist said he had been
"tormented by psychological demons" (as well
he should be), and other media reports indicate years
earlier he had confessed his treason to priests who
heard his confession and kept their silence. A
convoluted story. More to come. (Wash Post
17May01//p.1///Loeb, Masters, Pincus)(A. Thomson, http://www.intelforum.org)
(2) AUSTRALIAN -- A
former Australian intelligence agent was sentenced to 15
years in prison on 8 June 2001 for attempted espionage
after federal prosecutors told a judge that
Jean-Philippe Wispelaere, 30, had lived up to the terms
of his plea agreement and revealed all his illegal
activities, to wit, stealing more than 900 U.S.-produced
classified documents while working for the Australian
Defense Intelligence Organization and then trying to
sell them. Six days after he quit the Australian spy
service, Wispelaere walked into an unnamed country's
embassy in Bangkok and offered to sell the materials.
Sources identified the country as Singapore, which told
the United States of Wispelaere's offer. The FBI
launched a sting, paying Wispelaere $120,000 and luring
him to Dulles International Airport, where he was
arrested May 15, 1999. The Wispelaere case has dragged
on for nearly two years because the Australian was
diagnosed with schizophrenia after his arrest and was
declared temporarily unable to stand trial. A pathetic
case. (WashPost 9June01, p. B7// Masters)
(3) CUBAN -- Five
low-level Cuban agents were found guilty by a federal
jury on 8 June 2001 in Miami of spying on the US. They
were indicted in 1998 as part of the 14-member La Red
Avispa (Wasp) network. Their assignment was to
infiltrate the Cuban exile groups and to report on US
Southern Command military activities in the Caribbean.
Five other members of the spy ring had previously
pleaded guilty and received light sentences, and four
fled to Cuba. One of the agents, Gerardo Hernandez was
accused of sending a message to Havana about a planned
flight to drop propaganda leaflets in Cuba by some
members of the "Brothers to the Rescue" exile
group, some of whom were subsequently shot down by the
Cuban air force. `Four fliers died, and Hernandez faces
a life sentence.
None of the Cubans denied their activities and they
portrayed themselves as Cuban patriots trying to defend
their country from Cuban-American extremists in South
Florida. Two were assigned to report on US military
activities, and one found work as a janitor at a Key
West airbase, where he noted the comings and goings of
US airplanes. No concern has been expressed about damage
done to the US military by these spies. (WPost 9 June01,
p. A12)
(4) ARMY CIVILIAN --
The trial of US Army civilian (retired) George Trofimoff
(also a Colonel, USA/Reserve/retired),74, commenced in
Tampa, FL, on 6 June 01. He was accused, in a 32-count
indictment, of stealing classified documents while
serving as the civilian head of the US Army's Joint
Interrogation Center (JIC) in Nuremberg, Germany, and
selling them to the KGB. Trofimoff, born in Germany of
Russian parents, and naturalized in 1951, worked at the
JIC as a US Army civilian from 1969-1994, while also
being a member of the US Army Reserve. He was able to
retire in 1995 with the rank of Colonel -- a year after
having been arrested by the German government on
espionage charges in 1994, but released because
"the statute of limitations had expired." He
resigned from his post at the JIC in 1994 because of the
charges. He is said to have provided the KGB with 50,000
pages of documents, including US battle plans and briefs
on chemical and biological weapons. Although he is
described in the media as the highest ranking military
officer to be charged with espionage, to the great
irritation of many officers, he did his alleged dirty
work as a civilian employee of the Army. At least one
officer (AFIO member) who knew him at the JIC said he
was widely disliked. Trofimov, always in financial
trouble, and serving as a grocery store bag-boy to earn
a few extra nickels, fell for an FBI sting in 1997
promising him money. He denies all charges. (NYT
7June01, p. A18,Wpost 6June01 p.A3)
SUMMARY: These
indictments and trials are part of a series that began
with the arrest of CIA's Aldrich Ames in 1994 (life
imprisonment), continued with CIA's Harold Nicholson's
arrest in November 1996 (sentenced to 23 years),
followed by the FBI's Earl Pitts in December 1997 (27
years), the Army's intelligence specialist David Sheldon
Boone in October 98 (24 years), the arrest of the Navy's
Daniel King in November 99 (all charges dropped in March
2001), and the FBI's Robert Hanssen arraignment (June
2000) and former US Army civilian George Trofimoff's
trial. A sad list of traitors (King excepted), twisted
minds and betrayed loyalties. The Cubans, of course, are
not traitors, but foreign spies operating without
official diplomatic cover -- Cuban clandestine
operatives working for their country abroad, always a
risky business. (Jonkers)
ANOTHER NRO BUDGET FLAP???
-- In 1996, the NRO was found to have $2 to $3 billion
in unspent budget authority allegedly unbeknownst to
Congress -- some of which had gone into the new NRO
headquarters buildings then under construction in
Chantilly, VA. Congress had appropriated funds for
follow-on imagery satellite launches, but the existing
satellite(s) at the time outlived its/their expected
life span. So no launches were needed and the funds were
not yet spent - but were carried over. Congress,
however, charged they were not advised of these
"overhang" funds from past years.
Investigations ensued and the top two officials at NRO
were fired. According to a media report, a new budget
flap on this same type of issue has allegedly developed
and NRO Director Keith Hall is being blamed. It is hoped
wiser heads will prevail. (Macartney/Jonkers) (Wash
Times 8June01) http://www.washtimes.com/national/20010608-99623006.htm
SECTION II -
CONTEXT AND PRECEDENCE
CIA REORGANIZATION --
An item in WIN#21 on "Buzzy" Krongard's
appointment to the No.3 position at CIA was based on
media reporting. The more authoritative official context
for Mr. Krongard's role is to help implement the DCI's
"Strategic Direction," published two years
ago, in May 1998. A few days ago, on May 31st, the
occasion of the official abolition of the Directorate of
Administration as part of the recent CIA internal
realignment, Mr. Krongard emphasized that this
reorganization was an attempt to stress the mission over
bureaucratic procedures.
In Mr. Krongard's words to the CIA audience, "By .
. . removing the constraints of the bureaucracy . . .,
we can function more corporately. Taking a more
corporate approach ensures that all work being performed
directly or indirectly must contribute to mission. If it
doesn't, then you shouldn't be doing it .. ."
Why change? Said Mr. Krongard: "The complexity,
intricacy, and confluence of the threats facing our
national security necessitate fundamental change in the
way we, in the Intelligence Community, do our business.
It is our responsibility to ensure that our nation has
the intelligence it needs to anticipate and counter
threats." In terms of bureaucracy, mission
focus, and the changed environment for intelligence,
wise words that apply throughout the community.
(Jonkers)
CIA HONORS AIR AMERICA
-- For years they operated in secret -- civilian pilots
who worked for the CIA on missions they couldn't discuss
even with their families. Yesterday, 25 years after Air
America dissolved, the government finally recognized
these quiet heroes, 242 of whom died in the course of
accomplishing their missions.
The story of Air America began after World War II
in the 1940s when the Civil Air Transport commercial
airline was started in China. Pilots hauled relief
supplies and evacuated people throughout the country
during China's civil war. In 1950, the CIA bought the
airline to use in secret missions to fight communism in
Asia, and in 1959, CAT was renamed Air America. CAT and
Air America flew supplies, food and personnel to
anti-communist troops in Southeast Asia, including the
CIA's "secret war" in Laos. In 1975, Air
America helicopter crews helped evacuate Americans and
South Vietnamese from South Vietnam during the fall of
Saigon. The airline dissolved in 1976.
On 2 June some 850 former CAT and Air America pilots and
their families gathered in Las Vegas for their annual
reunion to swap stories and recall missions most
Americans know little about. They also honored the 242
people who died or disappeared during the missions. A
plaque honoring the missing and the dead hangs in the
McDermott Library at the University of Texas at Dallas.
A smaller version of the plaque is also in the CIA
headquarters in Langley, Va. But until now, CAT and Air
America workers had never been recognized by the CIA for
their service. A CIA representative presented a unit
citation.
Most members of the general public have probably never
heard of Air America, except for the 1990 Mel Gibson
movie by the same name. But the survivors gathered here
said that the movie didn't accurately portray what they
did in three decades of fighting in Southeast Asia. It
is a story that deserves to be told. Honors given where
honors are due. (Jonkers) (courtesy Peter Kessler
//Associated Press 3 June 01///A. Wagner)
CHINA REPORT -- A
startlingly frank new report from the Communist Party's
inner sanctum describes a spreading pattern of
"collective protests and group incidents"
arising from economic, ethnic and religious conflicts in
China and says relations between party officials and the
masses are "tense, with conflicts on the
rise." The unusual report, produced by a top party
research group and published this week by a Central
Committee press, describes mounting public anger over
inequality, corruption and official aloofness. (Jonkers)
(New York Times, June 3, 2001 // E. Eckholm) http://taiwansecurity.org/NYT/2001/NYT-060301.htm
// P. Yang
STRATEGIC ASSESSMENTS ON CHINA
-- The quarterly Defense Intelligence Journal devoted
its Winter 2001 issue to writings about China. Two short
excerpts follow:
(1) From the article by Admiral Dennis
C. Blair, CINCPAC (senior Navy Commander in the
Pacific) : "I cannot improve upon General Colin
Powell's advice to his intelligence officers. He told
his officers to tell him what they knew, what they did
not know, and what they inferred from the evidence
that they had. The validity of what they know and do
not know is their responsibility. What is inferred and
the action taken on that judgment is a shared
responsibility between the commander and the
intelligence officer....This is not the Cold War; it
is much more complicated. China is not the enemy of
the United States, but its insistence on its right to
use intimidation and aggression to achieve its aims
place it at odds with U.S. insistence upon the
peaceful resolution of disputes....The job of U.S.
military leaders is to ensure that, as the Chinese do
their 'calculations in the temple,' they never come to
believe that force can achieve their aims. We never
want them to make decisions similar to those that led
the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor. We do not want
them to calculate that it is to their advantage to use
military force, even if they do not win, as was the
case in the Chinese invasion of Vietnam in 1979."
(2) From an article by Dr. Bernard D. Cole, Associate
Dean for Faculty and Academic Affairs, National War
College: "China is not an expansionist nation,
but its sense of nationalism is so strong that Beijing
reserves to itself definition of such potent issues as
'sovereign rights,' 'territorial sovereignty,' and
'internal interference.' In other words, China wants
to define the playing field and game-rules for
pursuing its strategic objectives....China's framework
of strategic goals focuses on reuniting Taiwan with
the mainland, ensuring its ability to enforce
sovereignty over the South China Sea, and preventing
the emergence of a hegemonistic Japan in the region.
China historically has also campaigned to ensure that
nations on its periphery maintain at least a neutral
stance....China's strategic view historically focuses
on maintaining internal stability and controlling its
periphery....Emergence of an increasingly democratic
polity in China is not likely to change significantly
that nation's strategic view. Any government in
Beijing will have to place top priority on societal
stability, which today means, at a minimum,
maintaining a level of economic prosperity
satisfactory to most of China's population. Taiwan's
reunification will also continue to be a crucial
strategic issue, since no government will be able to
consider China fully unified without at least the pro
forma accession of the island to the mainland."
(Harvey) (Defense Intelligence Journal Vol. 10, No. 1,
Winter 2001)
"PASSIVE RADAR" AND
FUTURE STEALTH AIRCRAFT MISSIONS -- Technology
is always evolving, and for every weapon a
countermeasure is eventually developed -- offense and
defense shifting advantage. A recent media report
discussed the possibility of a microwave tower network
playing a role in detecting stealth aircraft tracks.
Virtually all airspace - and certainly that between and
among towers - is filled with microwave emissions.
Aircraft tracks disturb these radio waves and this can
be captured, patterned and displayed in a "passive
radar" mode. The radar does not emit. It may be
noted that there is always a significant gap in time and
capability between a theoretical paper possibility and
the actual weapon system becoming operational -- and
working as advertised, with an appropriate supporting
infrastructure, skill, training etc.. The
unsubstantiated media report, if valid, could
eventually/ potentially affect the planning of stealth
reconnaissance -intelligence missions
(Jonkers/Macartney).
http://abcnews.go.com/sections/world/DailyNews/radar_stealth_010614.html
SECTION III -
CYBER INTELLIGENCE
INTERNATIONAL HACKER ATTACK
SAMPLE --
(1) BRAZIL -- A hacker has invaded the
Brazilian government's energy crisis information
website. The 'Ministry Of Blackouts' site was blocked
for four hours. The hacker also published messages
contradicting the government's energy conservation
advice. Brazil is suffering its worst energy crisis
since the 1950s. President Cardoso set up the emergency
ministry to deal with the shortages and control the
rationing operation. http://www.ananova.com/news/story/sm_327741.html
(3) MALAYSIA --
Internet vandals defaced eight more Malaysian government
sites, highlighting the lax security and poor
maintenance among local network administrators. A group
known as "Silver Lords" claimed responsibility
through the German-based defacement mirror site
Alldas.de. The group replaced the main page of the sites
with a graphic entitled "For the love of
Kashmir." (Levine 6/15) http://www.newsbytes.com/news/01/166895.html
SECTION IV --
BOOKS AND SOURCES
REPORTS ON INTELLIGENCE ISSUES
PREPARED FOR CONGRESS -- A series of
unclassified and recently updated Congressional Research
Service (CRS) monographs summarize the intelligence
issues facing Congress in the coming year. The
intelligence committee members and their expert staffs
are very familiar with these issues, but many other
Senators and Representatives who are not on the
intelligence committees typically have no one on staff
who understands intelligence issues, nor do they have
staffs with necessary security clearances to use the
output of the committee staffs. This gap is addressed by
unclassified CRS studies which are prepared by Dick
Best, the CRS analyst for intelligence matters -- who
knows his stuff . (Macartney/Jonkers) (Aftergood)
http://www.fas.org/sgp/index.html]
INTELLIGENCE ISSUES FOR CONGRESS,
4June01
http://www.fas.org/irp/crs/IB10012.html
NSA: ISSUES FOR CONGRESS, 16Jan01
http://www.fas.org/irp/crs/RL30740.pdf
INTELLIGENCE & LAW ENFORCEMENT,
16Jan01
http://www.fas.org/irp/crs/RL30252.pdf
THE MILITARY POTENTIAL OF
CHINA'S COMMERCIAL TECHNOLOGY (online book), by
Roger Cliff (Rand, June 2001) This report examines
China's current commercial technology in eight
industries that have the most potential for supporting
military technology development, and assesses the
prospects for technological progress, in terms of
capabilities, effort, incentives, and institutions, over
the next 10 to 20 years. The findings suggest that even
though China's military will not be the U.S. military's
technological equal by 2020, the U.S. still must prepare
for a Chinese military whose capabilities will steadily
advance in the next 10 to 20 years. (Jonkers) http://www.rand.org/publications/MR/MR1292/
CHINA AND US FOREIGN POLICY IN
THE ASIA-PACIFIC: Living with American Dominance,
by Mike Smith and Nicholas Khoo (Briefing Paper, Royal
Institute of International Affairs, June 2001)
Increasingly, the stability of the Asia-Pacific region
appears to hinge on whether the Chinese can accept the
vigorous assertion of American regional primacy. While
this may be a bitter pill for China to swallow, it may
have no choice. Despite occasional irritation at US
foreign policy, fears of Chinese irredentism ensure that
Washington is still the hegemon of choice in the
Asia-Pacific. (Jonkers) (Philip Yang //Taiwan Security
Research: http://www.taiwansecurity.org/
)
IN THE SHADOW OF THE AYATOLLA: A
CIA HOSTAGE IN IRAN, by William Daugherty,
Naval Inst Press, Forthcoming, Oct 2001. Daugherty is
himself the former CIA hostage. He's also an AFIO member
and a ex-Marine who now teaches American government and
foreign policy at Armstrong Atlantic State U in
Savannah. Dustjacket blurbs will include comments from
author Jeff Richelson, ex-POW Dick Stratton, former
National Security Advisor Zbig Brzezinski, and
Ambassador Bruce Laingen. (Macartney)
SECTION V -
LETTERS AND NOTICES
MI6 CHIEF DIES -- The
Chief of MI6, David Spedding, died last week at the age
of 58. While Station Chief in Jordan in the 1980's he
had been credited with saving the life of Queen
Elizabeth who was targeted for assassination while
visiting that country.(courtesy[Kiracofe) (Macartney)
http://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/0,,56-2001200295,00.html
KOSOVO AND THE MYTH OF
INFORMATION SUPERIORITY -- This year old
article from the Spring 2000 issue of
"Parameters," the journal of the Army War
College, exposes a number of problems with the doctrine
of information warfare. [Namely, we are not as good at
it as we think we are and it may be impossible for
intelligence to operate well enough information-wise to
fulfill the doctrines being formulated in this area.)
(Macartney) (submitted by AFIO Chapter President BGen
Webb)
http://carlisle-www.army.mil/usawc/Parameters/00spring/thomas.htm
Dave B. writes on TRIDENT --
With regard to Mr. Earnest Oney's
letter in WIN 23-01, the TRIDENT organization was
quite operational as early as 1963. One of it's
primary operations was funneling arms and intelligence
to Kurdish rebels who were holding down substantial
number of Iraqi troops at the time. Israel had a
permanent liaison officer to the TNSS (Turkish
National Security Service) at the time. Interestingly,
the Jordanian Intelligence Service was a peripheral
partner in the organization early on.
(Las Cruces, NM)
WINs are protected by copyright laws.
Opinions expressed are those of the producer, editor(s)
and authors cited,
and do not represent AFIO positions.
Back issues are posted on the AFIO Website < www.afio.com>
with an eight-week delay.
Members are invited to keep AFIO vital and
growing by sponsoring new members and associate members.
Check our website for details.
Sponsors join the AFIO "Legion of
Merit."
Sponsors of five new members receive a gift item.
For comments, contact the editor Roy Jonkers at afio@afio.com
For back issues of the WIN, check the AFIO Website www.afio.com
For AFIO Website requests/comments, contact afio@afio.com
Back
to Top
About AFIO | Chapters
& Chapter Activities | Membership | Corporate
| Weekly Intelligence Notes | Event
Schedule | Bulletin Board | Legislative
| Careers | Donations | Book
Reviews | Search | AFIO
Store | | Other Intel Sites | Home
Page
AFIO Central Office
6723 Whittier Avenue, Suite 303A
McLean, Virginia 22101-4533
Telephone: 703 790 0320 | Facsimile: 703 790 0264
Email: afio@afio.com
|
|