Weekly
Intelligence Notes #23-01
11 June 2001
|
WIN #23-01
dated 11 June 2001
Weekly Intelligence Notes (WINs) are produced by Roy
Jonkers for the non-profit educational use by AFIO members
and WIN subscribers. Associate editors Macartney and
Harvey contribute articles to the WINs.
NOTICE TO MEMBERS: AFIO
will hold its annual Symposium and Convention on 2 and 3
November at a federal facility and a hotel located
in the Washington DC area. Members are invited to
recommend areas of high interest they would like to see
covered.
MEMBERS -- SPONSOR A NEW MEMBER TODAY! SUPPORT THE
AFIO MISSION!
SECTION I - CURRENT
INTELLIGENCE
DCI GEORGE TENET IN MIDDLE
EAST -- First,
in February, the Administration announced that the CIA
would no longer have a diplomatic role in mediating peace
between Israel and the Palestinians. The Agency had been
given that role at the Wye Island conference a couple of
years ago. Subsequently, in March, it was reported that
the CIA Chief of Station in Israel was hosting meetings
between Israeli and Palestinian security officials at the
US ambassador's
residence. When questioned on that, Administration
spokesmen said yes, but it was very "low key" -
neither mediation nor facilitation. On 4 June we heard
that the DCI, George Tenet, would travel to the Middle
East to mediate between Israeli and Palestinian security
leaders. More recent reports indicate that the DCI brought
a proposal for security arrangements to stop the killing
on both sides, but that neither side had as yet accepted
the document. US Intelligence is, of course, deeply
involved in the Middle East, declared or not, but the
renewed (and unusual) overt semi-diplomatic role for the
DCI is symptomatic of the volatility of the situation.
(Macartney) (WashPost 4-11 June 01)
RUSSIAN AIR DEFENSE MISSILE
EXPLOSION -- .A fire at a military base just
outside Moscow Friday caused an explosion and the
accidental launch of two rockets from one of Russia's most
modern anti-air defense units, Russian NTV television
reported. The fire in Ramenskoye, some 30 kilometers (18
miles) southeast of Moscow, spread to three S-300 units,
which exploded, launching two missiles into the air. The
explosion shattered windows in a neighboring village,
forcing its evacuation, the report said. (Agence France
Presse, 8 June 2001) (Zgram 11 June 01)
RUSSIAN SPACE IMAGERY
CAPABILITY RESUMES --
Russia's brief gap in operating a
photo-reconnaissance satellite came to an end on 29 May
with the launch of Cosmos 2377 from Plesetsk.
NATO EXERCISE IN GEORGIA
-- Some 4,000 NATO troops and dozens of warships began an
exercise in Georgia - the first in a former Soviet
republic. Russian leaders are concerned about the US-led
alliance's expansion into their sphere of influence. The
US is taking advantage of Russian weakness to expand its
influence and power in the Trans-Caucasus republics and
Central Asia. Oil is an important consideration in this
game. It is obviously an area of increased intelligence
interest. (Jonkers) (Chr.Sc.Monitor, 12 June 01, p. 20)
SECTION II -
CONTEXT AND PRECEDENCE
AFGHANISTAN -- GIVING THE
DEVIL HIS DUE -- There has been a paucity of
media reporting on a favorable development in
international crime -- the abrupt cessation of
Afghanistan poppy growing. Last July, the Taliban banned
the growing of poppies as a sin against the teachings of
Islam in a ruling by the supreme leader of the faithful,
Mullah Muhammad Omar. In February, United Nations
narcotics officials began to report that poppy cultivation
was ceasing -- a significant event since Afghanistan has
accounted for three-quarters of the world's opium (heroin)
production. By May, American officials and outside press
representatives had confirmed that the Taliban had,
indeed, stopped poppy cultivation. The move has been
especially painful for the country which is in the fourth
year of a calamitous drought. The relatively
drought-resistant poppy would have provided vital income
to the million people facing a very serious shortage of
food and water before summer's end. The US has recently
announced a $43 million grant for drought relief in
Afghanistan, but the speculation is that many of the poppy
farmers will become poppy refugees.
Although
the Taliban did not seek international aid packages in
advance of the poppy ban [usually the case for a country
plowing under some drug crop], it has been looking to the
developed world to compensate its efforts in some fashion.
Despite stressing the poppy ban as rooted in religious
principles, the Taliban has not outlawed opium possession
or sale. Since opium stockpiles exist, some smart traders
have squirreled away their opium and are profiting from
the rising prices. Local betting is that the ban on poppy
production will hold up. It is not known what the
intelligence community is doing to divine the consequences
of the Taliban action in relation to the international
drug trade. Increased production in other regions is easy
to predict, but there are almost certainly unanticipated
consequences requiring early detection.(Harvey) ( NY Times
11 Feb, '01 // B. Crossette; NY Times 24 May, '01 // B.
Bearak)
THE US WAR ON DRUGS IN LATIN
AMERICA -- The war to eradicate narcotics
cultivation in Colombia continues. It currently features
increased ferocity by
the brutal private paramilitary forces operating on
behalf of the plantation owners (now reported to be
employing chain-saw mutilations and killings of peasants),
and our targets, the FALC, who have their own terror
measures to keep the peasants in line.
US
special operations and air support capabilities in the
area were enhanced on 29 May when the Dutch Parliament
voted in favor of an agreement to provide operating use
for US armed forces on two airfields in the Netherlands
Antilles, off the coast of Venezuela. (Jonkers) (Jane�s 6
June01// http://www.janes.com
via their This Week e-mail alert)
US COMPUTER EXPORT
RESTRICTIONS QUESTIONED -- The Center for
Strategic and International Studies published a study
concluding that US restrictions on exports of
sophisticated computer hardware are an
"irrelevant" relic of the Cold War that should
be scrapped. It notes that the limits on technology
exports based on computing power make little sense in
light of the new political and technological realities,
and may end up hurting an industry that is vital to US
interests. "Export controls on information technology
derive from an era when the strategy of the United States
and is allies was to deny technology to the Soviet Union
and keep the Western alliance strong ... This is no longer
the case." (Z-gram 11 June) (Agence France Presse, 8
June 2001)
CONGRESS LOOKING INTO CIA's
IN-Q-TEL -- Three years after the CIA began
pouring millions of dollars into an unclassified venture
capital fund called In-Q-Tel, Congress has convened a
panel of technical experts to determine whether the
initiative is worth the money in the face of emerging
Internet technologies. (Macartney)
(http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A12582-2001Jun2.html)
RUSSIA's MILITARY DECAY --
The Russian military fell to pauper level under former
president Boris Yeltsin. In numbers it shrank from 2.7
million to 1.2 million troops, and its budget shrank even
faster. A soldier's pay is about a dollar a month.
Soldiers are sometimes forced to ask townspeople for
toothbrushes and soap, or work in local shops in exchange
for supplies. Officers moonlight driving taxis and loading
trucks. Thousands of soldiers desert every year, and the
suicide rate is
four times as high as in US forces. Brutality in the ranks
is legendary - soldiers undergo painful hazing, are
frequently abused, and at least 500 soldiers a year are
murdered by their peers. Equipment is decrepit, training inadequate,
and the conscripts, increasingly, are society's rejects.
In charge of the remnants of the USSR's weapons, they must
have been most vulnerable to intelligence exploitation.
President
Putin is trying to reform the military, reducing it
further in size, raising military pay, and setting a goal
of a professional volunteer force. But in conjunction he
may have to adjust Russia's expectations of a super-power
role in the world and accept a lesser power position. The
predecessor USSR could not compete with the US and its
$300 Billion military super-budget, and present-day Russia
is but pale shadow of its former incarnation. Putin's
government will do well to keep together the Russian state
as it exists today.
Being
less powerful means that Russia must have greater relative
reliance on its intelligence services -- even though
Russian state and military intelligence organizations were
deeply damaged during the past decade and made extremely
vulnerable to foreign (including US) intrusion.
Nevertheless, the war of the spies and counter-spies with
Russia will continue, as it will be with many others, and
has been since history began. Russian spy - and FBI
traitor - Hanssen
is but one small expression of this reality. (Jonkers)
Wpost May22, 2001, p. A1)
RUSSIAN COMBAT DEATHS 1918
2001 PUBLISHED -- The Russian General Staff
released the following information on Russian combat
deaths from their Civil War up through today's
Chechen War.
As published in "Argumenty i fakty,"
No. 22, the Soviet military lost 939,755 soldiers during
their Civil War (1918-22), 626 in the struggle against
the basmachi movement in Central Asia (1923-31), 187 in
the 1929 Soviet-Chinese conflict, 353 in the Spanish
Civil War, 9,920 in battles with the Japanese at the end
of the 1930s, and 1,139 during the occupation of Western
Ukraine and Western Belarus. During the Soviet- Finnish
War the Soviet side lost 126,875. During World War II
they suffered a staggering number of 8,668,400 dead.
During the Korean War (1950-53), the Soviet forces lost
299 in combat against the Americans. During military
assistance operations in Asia and Africa 145 Soviet
soldiers died; in Hungary in 1956, 750; and in
Czechoslovakia in 1968, 96 were killed. During the 1969
border dispute with China, 60 Soviet soldiers were
killed. The Afghan war claimed 14,751 Soviet soldiers'
lives. In the first Chechen war, 5,835 Russian soldiers
died, and in the second 3,108 have died so far.
Particularly noteworthy are the 299 combat
deaths listed in the Korean war --
the seldom mentioned war of the Soviet Air Force
against our tactical air forces in North Korea, which was
the only sustained direct Soviet-US combat during the
so-called Cold War. The other interesting statistics are
the enormous losses sustained by the Soviets during their
war against Finland in 1939/40, when it appeared that the
Soviet Army could not fight their way out of a paper bag
-- almost like today. The recent losses in Chechnia
are noteworthy mostly for their steady drain of casualties
impacting on public perceptions -- which we can remember
from the Vietnam War. (Jonkers) (Moscow - Argumenty I
fakty No 22)
SECTION III - CYBER
INTELLIGENCE
US IT INDUSTRY CONDEMNS EU
CONVENTION ON CYBERCRIME -- IT industry gurus
have branded the Council Of Europe's Convention on
Cybercrime 'foolish, unworkable and a legal con trick.'
The controversial treaty provides a blanket legislation to
deal with all forms of internet crime from hacking to
online pornography. Caspar Bowden, director of internet
think-tank FIPR, said: "The Convention is essentially
a legal con trick, drafted in secret by a handful of
nameless bureaucrats."
It
equates the internet - a network of private networks -
with 'cyberspace,'
a metaphor from science fiction. "By this sleight of
hand, the internet is defined as a public space over which
law enforcement should be granted unfettered powers of
surveillance and extradition," he added. The
requirement for preservation of data traffic for a 90-day
period has infuriated the industry. But many claim it is
the lesser of two evils. Preservation orders are not
mandatory - unlike data retention - but imposed by law
enforcement agencies involved in specific investigations.
(Levine 11 June) http://uk.news.yahoo.com/010608/36/bufop.html
SECTION IV - BOOKS
AND SOURCES
DEFENSE DEPARTMENT HUMINT
DOCUMENTS ON WEBSITE -- Throughout the Cold War,
the CIA has had principal responsibility for clandestine
HUMINT, but the armed services maintained their own HUMINT
activities. These were mostly (but not only) overt
collectors -- defense attach�s and refugee and defector
debriefing facilities. In the early 1990's, partly in
response to conclusions in the Pentagon and on Capitol
Hill that CIA HUMINT support of the Desert /Shield Storm
operations had been inadequate, military HUMINT was beefed
up. The Defense HUMINT Service (DHS) was established at
DIA. It consolidated management of DIA's Defense Attach�
System (DAS) and brought it together with coordination and
management of Service HUMINT operations. The National
Security Archive website offers 21 documents about or by
the DHS from the period 1965 to 1995. (Macartney)
http://www.gwu.edu/~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB46/
THE UNITED STATES AND ASIA
-- Toward a New U.S. Strategy and
Force Posture -- Report by the Rand Corporation, May 2001,
<http://www.rand.org/publications/MR/MR1315/>(PDF
File) Asia is beset by a variety of problems that could
well imperil the stability it has long enjoyed --
including territorial disputes, nuclear rivalry, rising
nationalist sentiments, and increased military
capabilities. This report summarizes the manner in which
the United States can best meet these challenges and
thereby ensure continued peace and stability in the
region. (Assoc.Prof P. Yang, Natl Taiwan U)
SECTION V - LETTERS
& NOTICES
AFIO SCHOLARSHIPS.
AFIO is now sponsoring or managing several very attractive
scholarship opportunities for college students, both grads
and undergrads. Because applications have been few (not
very many young people think of AFIO as a scholarship
source), they have just extended the deadline until July
1st. So, if you are a student or the parent of a student,
you may want to check this out.
https://www.afio.com/13_scholarships.htm
LETTER -- Earnest R
ONEY writes:
I have just read Carroll's article,
"Ankara's Strategic Alignment with Tel
Aviv..." mentioned in WIN#22 and thought you, and
perhaps others, might like a bit more. As Carroll points
out the Turkish-Israeli alignment became public in 1993.
However, contacts had started perhaps as much as twenty
years earlier. Turkey, Israel and Iran had a secret
relationship, which they called Trident, starting in the
1970s and perhaps earlier. This was primarily an
information exchange and liaison among the security
services on problems of mutual interest, mostly dealing
with the Arab States for obvious reasons. There was also
an exchange of intelligence officers. The Iranian
officer in Israel at the time of the 1979 Islamic
Revolution was , of course, recalled to Tehran and, I am
told, escaped the firing squad because his wife had good
connections in the religious establishment. There was a
substantial Israeli presence in Tehran and this was a
major point that the Islamic militants held against the
Shah's regime which had recognized Israeli 'de facto,'
if not 'de jure.' I suspect that intelligence exchange
continued between Turkey and Israel continued after
Iran's defection in 1979 and the 1993 exchange of
official visits and the 1994 "Agreement on
security" and the "Memorandum on Mutual
Understanding and Cooperation" has moved this
relationship to a higher and more public position.
And this ties in, in a sense, with the Iraqi
propaganda also mentioned in WIN #22 where Saddam's
mouthpiece newspaper commenting on Iran's nuclear
capabilities writes "It means that Iran, Turkey and
the Zionist entity agree on one goal and one hostile
policy toward the Arab entity." (Trident
re-visited!).
And to wander a bit further afield I note the
same Iraqi newspaper claiming that three small islands
commanding the Straits of Hormuz really belong to Iraq.
In fact, of course these islands Abu Musa and the two
Tunbs belonged to the Sheikdoms of Sharjah and Ras al-Kaymah
respectively and were seized by the Shah's Iran after
the British pulled out of the Gulf in 1971
(Earnest R ONEY)
LETTER -- Joe Goulden
writes on James Bamford�s new book:
AFIO member Tom Powers has a splendid
review of James Bamford's new NSA book, BODY OF
SECRETS, in The New York Review of Books,
21 June 2001, pp. 51-54. Powers' concluding paragraph
makes a valuable point in the best language I've seen.:
"And that brings us back to the exasperated
question of bystanders who feel they are watching
toddlers squabble in the sandbox. Why can't these great
powers get along? Why do they have to keep pushing and
probing each other in these aggressive ways -- cracking
codes, suborning spies, stealing documents, bugging
embassies, sending ships and aircraft bristling with
antennae into harm's way? The answer, richly documented
in Bamford's book, is that in international competition
for power, where differences sometimes lead to war, what
intelligence organizations do -- all the huggermugger of
the great game -- may look like strife, but it's the
closest serious international rivals ever get to
peace." [Joe Goulden]
(Ed. Comments Tom Powers review is
first-rate indeed // RJ)
Weekly Intelligence Notes (WINs) contain commentaries on
intelligence-related events and developments based on
public open-source information The opinions expressed are
those of the editor(s)or authors noted and do not
represent any AFIO position, but reflect generally on the
role and importance of intelligence to US national
security and interests. WINs are protected by copyright
laws.
AFIO MEMBERS - SPONSOR A NEW MEMBER -- WE
NEED TO GROW TO SURVIVE AND ACCOMPLISH OUR MISSION!!
KEEP AFIO SOLVENT - SPONSOR A
CORPORATE PARTNER!
CHECK AFIO's WEBSITE - ALWAYS KEPT CURRENT - FOR
DETAILS
For comments, contact the editor Roy Jonkers at afio@afio.com
For back issues of the WIN, check the AFIO Website www.afio.com
For AFIO Website requests/comments, contact afio@afio.com
Back
to Top
About AFIO | Chapters
& Chapter Activities | Membership | Corporate
| Weekly Intelligence Notes | Event
Schedule | Bulletin Board | Legislative
| Careers | Donations | Book
Reviews | Search | AFIO
Store | | Other Intel Sites | Home
Page
AFIO Central Office
6723 Whittier Avenue, Suite 303A
McLean, Virginia 22101-4533
Telephone: 703 790 0320 | Facsimile: 703 790 0264
Email: afio@afio.com
|
|